Wednesday, November 18, 2026 · The Health Policy Podcast
Health Policy Podcast logo

Receive new episodes in your inbox.

← Health Policy Podcast
Regulation & Policy

2026-11-17 · Center for Modern Health

Mapping Medical Freedom: Key Insights from the 2026 Health Freedom Index

with Jared Rhoads, Founder and Executive Director, Center for Modern Health — Center for Modern Health

Mapping Medical Freedom: Key Insights from the 2026 Health Freedom Index

The 2026 Health Freedom Index, jointly produced with the Knee Regulatory Research Center, evaluates all 50 states and Washington, D.C., across 54 policy variables, says Jared Rhoads, founder and executive director of the Center for Modern Health, in a Health Policy Podcast interview with Bryan Hyde. Jointly produced with the Knee Regulatory Research Center, the report evaluates all 50 states and Washington, D.C., across 54 policy variables grouped into professional, institutional, patient, payment, and delivery freedom. Rhoads explains why healthcare freedom defies traditional partisan assumptions—highlighting top-ranking states like Arizona and Colorado—while identifying why heavily regulated states such as New Jersey and New York scored near the bottom. The conversation highlights practical, nonpartisan policy opportunities for state lawmakers, including the repeal of certificate-of-need laws, expanded prescriptive authority for psychologists, and broader Right to Try protections.

Mapping Medical Freedom: Key Insights from the 2026 Health Freedom Index

0:00 / 0:00

About the guest

Jared Rhoads, Founder and Executive Director, Center for Modern Health at Center for Modern Health

Jared Rhoads

Founder and Executive Director, Center for Modern Health — Center for Modern Health

Jared Rhoads, MPH, MS. Jared Rhoads is the Founder and Executive Director of the Center for Modern Health. His writings on health policy have appeared in a wide range of publications. He received his MPH degree from the Geisel School of Medicine at Dartmouth, and an MS degree from Bentley University. He also teaches health policy in the graduate public health program at Dartmouth, and advises graduate students on their independent research projects. Jared has published research with a variety of think tanks, including the Mercatus Center at George Mason University, the Center for Ethics in Society at St. Anselm University, and the Foundation for Government Accountability. Prior to teaching, he worked in healthcare consulting in a role that handled policy and emerging practices. Email: jared.rhoads@centerformodernhealth.org.

Full transcript

Show full transcript
[00:00] Bryan Hyde: Welcome to the Health Policy Podcast. I'm Bryan Hyde, and I'm joined by Jared Rhoads, who is the founder and executive director of the Center for Modern Health. Jared, it's wonderful to have you back on the program. [00:10] Jared Rhoads: To be back. Thanks for the invitation. [00:12] Bryan Hyde: So for those who are meeting you for the first time, take a moment, tell us a little bit about who you are, and tell us about the Center for Modern Health. [00:19] Jared Rhoads: Yes, so the Center for Modern Health is a free market health policy think tank. Physically, I'm located in New Hampshire, but that does not mean that we are, you know, focused on that state or anything. Our team is distributed distributed across the US. And we do health policy on issues that are state-based, things that are federal in nature. We also do— I also try to make a point of saying this from time to time is that we also do sort of like high-level kind of meta issues, things that get to like fundamental questions and even just sort of shaping the way we even think about healthcare because there are a lot of things that kind of traps that we get ourselves into where, you know, if we're only focused on like the policy options directly in front of us, sometimes we, you know, kind of forget that, wait a second, this whole, you know, this whole, you know, choice architecture is being presented to us because we made some assumption, you know, earlier and we haven't revisited that assumption. So sometimes it makes a lot of sense to go back and like question how we even got to some places. So we do, yeah, so we do work on all sorts of levels like that. And so like in normal think tank. We put out articles and commentaries and, you know, data kind of reports and analyses, and as well as, you know, give talks. And we have— we've got a podcast ourselves and that sort of thing. So we get involved in all of the normal think tank kind of activities. And we're a nonprofit 501. So if anybody out there wants to support us, we'll happily take that. [01:56] Bryan Hyde: I'm anxious and excited to dig into your 2026 Health Freedom Index and specifically quickly, uh, to, to talk about how, um, how health freedom may, may differ from state to state. Uh, tell me a little bit about the index itself first, and, and what was the thinking behind it? [02:13] Jared Rhoads: Sure. So this is, uh, if you're familiar with, um, any sort of freedom index, and there are other ones out there, there's like the World Economic, uh, Freedom Index where, you know, the different, different countries are ranked against each other to see which country is the freest. And, and, uh, and there's, there's other types of, you know, there's like a free, free speech index that, that people have put out there. This is kind of This is a big report, a big project that we undertook in conjunction with the NEE Regulatory Center. They're a university-based research group that we just have a good relationship with. And so the two of us and two of our organizations got together to jointly publish and do this work. So this, this, this Health Freedom Index, what we do is we look at each of the 50 states plus Washington, D.C. So it's actually 51 observations there. And we are— we're taking a look at lots of different health policy issues and areas within those states and basically trying to give a ranking to those states based on how free or not they are. So the standard we've set is, are you relatively free in a given area? And free would mean, you know, leaving things to market forces or, you know, not regulating things really strictly, you know, more patient freedom, things like that. So it's like a lighter touch or not regulating something at all that gets you more points in the way that this Freedom Index works. And if you are a state that in a given area, like some licensing area or the way that you restrict facilities getting built or something like that, whatever the policy area, if you are a state that really heavily regulates that or bans it, prohibits it, whatever the case may be, then we look at that relative to freedom, that's being a bad thing. So you'd get a low score in that. So then we just do that for lots and lots of issues. And at the end of that whole exercise, with each state getting a 5 on this and a 3 on that and 1 point on here and 3 points over there, tallying that all up, you end up with a ranking, which is kind of fun to look at. And we get to say that at the end, when the dust settles, such and such a state is the freest and the and others are less free, and then that becomes a good sort of conversation starter. [04:41] Bryan Hyde: Jared, if you would, unpack for us the 5 categories that you examine all these different policy variables across. [04:49] Jared Rhoads: Sure. Yeah. So there's 54 different individual policies that we're looking at, but 54 is a big number. And so some people just want to know sort of the higher level kind of where does it— how does it look? And so we kind of categorize those 54 different things into 5 categories, and that's that's what you're talking about. There are a bunch that fall into the category of professional freedom, for instance. So that's things like anything having to do with licensure. How difficult is it to get a medical license in a state? How much postgraduate training does a state require you to do? What about continuing medical education requirements? Anything that's about that professional part, thinking of the physicians, Mm-hmm. the clinicians and the nurses and the midwives and everybody who could possibly be involved in care where we can get good data from. What kinds of regulations are there on those people? So there's professional freedom. That's the first category. The next category is institutional freedom. And this is like, what kind of regulations are there on institutions in the sense of hospitals, if you want to open up a freestanding birth center, or if you want to have a freestanding emergency department, like an urgent care kind of thing. So if you think about organizations, we call it institutions, but what kind of regulations or controls are there on those types of entities? Again, sort of like a step removed from the professionals, more about the institution. So that's a whole category. Then there's a category on patient freedom. As you would imagine, this is things that directly say whether you can— what you can do as a patient. Are you allowed to take a psychedelic if you think that it's going to help you with your depression or something like that? Things like that. Access to different types of care. So patient freedom is a whole category. And then there's payment freedom, which has to do with insurance regulations and what kinds of arrangements can you make to either pay out of pocket or not? Is that allowed? Is that really hard to do in your state? And then the final category of these 5 is delivery freedom. And what we're talking about there is healthcare modalities, healthcare delivery. It's things like regulations that have to do with telemedicine, for instance. What kind of things can you do online versus in person? In some states, you can have an an eye exam online. In other states, nope, that's not allowed and you've got to be there in person, right? And so you can see there's a freedom issue there. We would say all else equal, it should be up to the patients and up to the patients and their physician to decide whether an online eye exam is good enough or whether it's not. And don't let the bureaucrats decide that. So yeah, so those are the 5. Real quickly, again, it's professional, institutional, patient, payment, and then delivery. That's a big, big long answer, but at least we have some framework now, right? [08:16] Bryan Hyde: Well, that sounds like a lot of great data from which to start looking at the individual states. And, and let's, let's break it down into some of the broader categories. You've got red states, blue states, and purple states. Is it fair to start asking which are among the best states for medical freedom? [08:34] Jared Rhoads: Sure, happy to. Yeah. And I'll also say I'm kind of happy to say that it's not really like, oh, red states walk away with all the victories, or like, oh, the blue states are dominant or something. It's actually a more interesting story than that, which is that they all— there's kind of interesting representation of all different types. So red, blue, and purple. At the top of the rankings is Arizona, and Arizona is a purple state, at least according to the The reference that we use is the Cook Political Report. So for the categorizations of what color a state is. So Arizona was our number 1 overall state. Number 2 was a blue state, actually. That's Colorado. They're actually pretty good on this right now. The next couple, the next several are all red states. But again, it really doesn't dominate. So Idaho was 3rd, North Dakota was 4th, Utah was 5th. Normally I stop with 5, but I'll mention the 6th because it's New Hampshire. That's my state. So New Hampshire was 6th. And then there again, that's actually like a kind of a switch back to a blue state because New Hampshire is sometimes thought of as a blue state. It's actually a little bit more complicated than that. We're kind of like purplish in a blue neighborhood, but we can talk about that later. So anyway, yeah, it's interesting that I think what it shows is that clearly this isn't just us trying to rig it to make some states look good and others not, and others bad or something. We have selected the variables that we cover in really as broad a way as possible. When we try to figure out whether to include a variable or not, one of these policy variables that we score the states on, we're looking for things like, can we get the data on it? Is there a clear demarcation between different states. If all states are doing the same thing, there's kind of less of a case for including it as a variable unless we're trying to accomplish something else by like, you know, if it's a— we do have one variable, for instance, where all the states got a 1, meaning like because they're not doing it. And we sort of put it in there because like, hey, this is an aspirational thing that, you know, maybe all states could, if they see this, they could think of it as an opportunity. But for the most part, you know, we're looking for variables where It's just based on, is the data there that we can get? And what kind of— is there some variety? Does it say something? Does it measure something like that? And is there a clear pro-freedom stance, which we'd be happy to give a 5 to, and a clear non-freedom-related stance where we would say, okay, yeah, that's fair to say that that's a 1? And so, yeah, anyway, it's nice to see that there's a mix of red, blue, and purple. And we even did this kind of analysis, and it's not even statistic— I ran the statistical analysis to see if it was statistically significant, the differences between the sort of averages of the red, blue, and purple states. And it wasn't, which is to say that the group averages do not differ statistically. The red states and purple states came out slightly ahead of the blue, but it wasn't enough to say that, oh yeah, it's clearly like they're walking away with, you know, way more free than the blue. It's not that kind of story exactly. [12:17] Bryan Hyde: I can understand why you want to, you know, take the ideological lean out of it, because there's some people that hear blue or they hear red and boom, their mind's gonna slam shut because of their own ideological preferences. Now, having asked about the best states, I, you know, of course I wanna know, so what are the worst states when it comes to health freedom? [12:35] Jared Rhoads: Totally, yeah, yeah. Now, so now this is an area where there's some, you know, the bottom half of the distribution is kind of dominating. by one color, and that would be, I'd say it goes a bit blue. Unfortunately, there are some states. New Jersey was the absolute— they were 51 out of 51. Massachusetts was 50th. New York was 49th. Rhode Island was 48th. California, 47th. So very blue at the bottom. Again, the rest of the— at the top, it's mixed. Even in the middle, it's kind of mixed. But yeah, A lot of the blue states do end up at the bottom. That comes down to things like, you know, with several of the categories having to do with like professional freedom and institutional freedom and payment freedom right there, like sort of 3 out of the 5 categories, I guess, are— have to do with like things that track with maybe economic freedom, you know. And unfortunately, for whatever reason, I won't psychologize, but, you know, for whatever reason, the blue states do like to control with greater amounts of regulation the institutions that surround them and the way that people pay for care. I think they think they're doing good by having price controls on things and that sort of thing, but it's not a very pro-freedom approach. And so it does hurt them in that. If I can say something nice about the blue states, though, for a moment, they do win the patient freedom. So in that particular category, okay, hey, they're sort of more likely to let you— again, psychedelics in terms of treating certain medical issues. So that kind of issue. There's some reproductive kind of freedom issues where they're more sort of free on that. Some prescribing kinds of freedoms that they're decent on. And I think there's also Also in that category, there is— oh, we even capture something, and I know this is controversial, but medical aid in dying. I think that's something that the blue states are noticeably more free on. There's a few blue states where they allow that, whereas the red states don't. So again, patient-level stuff, arguably the blue states are a little little bit freer on that. [15:14] Bryan Hyde: So let's— we've only got about 4 minutes left in our segment here, but let's talk about the big takeaways. And specifically, when it comes to places where, where the states can improve in terms of health freedom, what were some of the things you learned that, that you would want our listeners to know? [15:30] Jared Rhoads: Yeah. Oh boy. Um, I think, you know, so the, the real reason we do this is, uh, it's not exactly to get the rankings. I mean, the rankings are fun to talk about, and, you know, you— if your state does well, you get to gloat, and if your state does, or somebody, some colleague is in a state that doesn't do well, you can point that out to them. But honestly, it's really to be able to capture those policy-level scores and then look for opportunities. And so, just in the past couple of days with the sort of blue states doing really well in the midterm elections, it has us thinking now like, okay, well, What can this Freedom Index help us do in terms of identifying opportunities? So what you want to look at then is looking through the scores and see where has a blue state not done well, but they've not done well on an issue that is not necessarily anti-freedom or something, like something where they could do better on, and it doesn't go against the grain to expect that they could do better on that. One of our variables is number 6. We have them all numbered. One of them is number 6. It has to do with granting psychologists prescriptive authority. So you can have a psychologist write a prescription for an anxiety medicine or something like that. That's a very— there's no red or blue thing about that, but they don't do well on that. And so that's one area where blue states could could look at kind of expanding the scope of practice there for psychologists. And that's just a, I don't know, a good thing. It's sort of for the patients involved, it's sort of like maybe one less, it's more convenient. It's maybe one less visit that they don't have to then get referred to somebody else to get a medication that they could reasonably get from a psychologist. So anyway, things like that. You might also look at certificate of need laws. I mean, this comes up in a lot of our work, actually. There's kind of no reason that— that's not like an inherent red versus blue kind of issue. Like, why couldn't blue states be better on certificate of need laws? Certificate of need laws are these laws that say that you have to get a special permission slip in order to expand your hospital or add some beds or add an MRI machine to your facility. Why is that? That doesn't need to track with political valence to it. So blue states, now that they've got more power and more influence here, why not look at that and try to get some blue states to repeal or pare back their certificate of need laws? So those are just a couple. I'll name one more. I know we're short on time. Name another one like Like patients and right to try. You know, blue states don't haven't done well on that. The red states and the purple states are much more likely to to say, "Hey, look, if you're especially if you're terminally ill or something, but even if you're not terminally ill, if you just want to you know you're down to your few options, last few options, and there's an investigational drug that somebody's working on, you can't get into the into the randomized controlled trial, or it's it's just it's not a." you're excluded for some reason. Why not be able to approach them and have that opportunity to try that? There's no inherent political categorization to that. So why couldn't blue states be better on that? I think they could. What it comes down to oftentimes is that they defer a lot to the FDA, But I think, I think maybe it would be a wise time to say, well, let's, let's, let's, let's be less kind of beholden to the FDA on that and allow patients to— I mean, hey, if blue states are kind of pro-patient freedom, that's like a patient freedom kind of thing. So, you know, why not? Why not ask blue states to revisit that one? So. [19:49] Bryan Hyde: Okay. One final question for you, Jared, and that is, where can people access this study? [19:54] Jared Rhoads: Yeah, thank you. It's centerformodernhealth.org is our website. And right at the top, you'll see the report. And then you'll also see this sort of like spinoff article where we do a couple like specialized analyses. And that's on there too. But yeah, centerformodernhealth.org is where you'll find all our stuff. And yeah, thanks again. [20:14] Bryan Hyde: Again, we've been visiting with Jared Rhodes. He's the executive director of the Center for Modern Health. And Jared, thanks once again for joining us on the Health Policy Podcast. [20:23] Jared Rhoads: Sure thing. Thank you.